Sarah's Pudding - the ultimate after dinner treat

Fabulously easy, deliciously decadent and bad for you in the best possible way, this oh-so-simple recipe is the perfect sexy after-dinner treat.

Named after a lady called Sarah who knew what she was doing in the pudding department. Sarah - we thank you!

The Muscovado sugar has a significant molasses hit which gives you deep, caramel flavours.  

During refrigeration the sugar melts and liquifies, marbling down through the creamy centre to leave an almost crisp topping and a little lake of rich, slightly bitter liquid at the bottom of the glass.

Oh my word, it's naughty.

You can make this in a big bowl if you want to feed a crowd, or if it's just for the two of you, serve in glasses.


  • Equal quantities double cream and full fat yoghurt (quantity depends entirely on how many you are serving).
  • Dark Muscovado sugar - make sure it's fresh or it won't melt.


  1. Whip the cream to soft peaks.
  2. Gently combine with the yoghurt.
  3. Sprinkle the Muscovado sugar on top to a depth of at least 3mm.
  4. Chill in fridge for a minimum of 24 hours - don't stint on this time period; it won't work.

Prep time 10 minutes.  Resting time 24 hours 

Leave a comment

Sign up to receive our latest news

Subscribe to our newsletter and enter our competition - we are giving away an embossed apron once a month.